Heisman Odds 2026: Jeremiah Smith Climbs With 3 Weeks Left

With about three weeks left in the college football regular season, the Heisman market is shifting. Ohio State's Jeremiah Smith is gaining ground while Mestemaker is losing it.

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

Key points

  • Recent Bleacher Report coverage has Jeremiah Smith rising in the Heisman odds and Mestemaker falling.
  • Smith became the first Big Ten receiver to reach 4,000 career receiving yards, per 247Sports.
  • Odds shift weekly and differ by sportsbook, so check current numbers before drawing conclusions.
  • Wide receivers rarely win the Heisman, which is part of why Smith's rise is notable.
  • The final weeks, including rivalry games and conference title games, usually decide the race.

What's happening with the Heisman odds

The Heisman market is moving again with roughly three weeks left in the season. Bleacher Report's latest odds roundup says Ohio State receiver Jeremiah Smith is rising and Mestemaker is dropping. NCAA.com has also published a ranking of the top contenders at the three-weeks-to-go mark, which is a usual checkpoint in the race.

Exact odds change by the day and vary between sportsbooks, so this article doesn't quote specific prices. Check a current source if you want the latest numbers.

Why it's trending now

Two things are driving the searches. First, late November is when the Heisman race tightens. Candidates have played most of their schedules, and what remains is rivalry weekend and conference championship games. Those are the games voters remember when they fill out ballots.

Second, Smith just hit a milestone. According to 247Sports, he is the first Big Ten receiver to reach 4,000 career yards. That is a career-longevity mark rather than a single-season stat, but it adds to the argument that he is among the most productive receivers the conference has seen.

Why Jeremiah Smith's rise stands out

Smith arrived at Ohio State as one of the most hyped recruits in recent memory and played a big role on the Buckeyes' national championship team in his freshman season. Since then, "best receiver in the country" has been a common description.

The Heisman has historically favored quarterbacks and running backs. Receivers do win, but rarely. The last pure wide receiver to take the trophy was DeVonta Smith of Alabama in 2020. Travis Hunter won in 2024 while playing both receiver and cornerback, which showed voters will back a non-quarterback with a standout case.

For a receiver, the case usually needs three things: huge numbers, a team that is winning at the top of the rankings, and a signature game or two that people talk about for days. Smith's odds improving suggests bettors think he is building that case.

Why Mestemaker's odds are falling

The headline says Mestemaker is falling, but it doesn't give the reason. Odds usually drop for a few common reasons: a loss, a statistically quiet game, a stronger rival candidate, or a team slipping in the rankings. We'll avoid guessing which one applies here. Check the full Bleacher Report piece or the player's recent game logs.

How to read Heisman odds

Heisman odds are usually shown in American format, such as +500 or +1200. A few basics:

  • Higher plus number, longer shot. +1200 means the market sees a lower chance than +500.
  • Payout. At +500, a $100 bet would return $500 in profit if it wins, plus your stake.
  • Implied probability. +500 works out to about a 16.7% implied chance, before the sportsbook's margin. The full list of candidates adds up to more than 100% because of that margin.
  • Movement matters. A player whose price shortens, say from +800 to +400, is gaining market confidence. Writers often call that "rising."

Odds are not predictions, and they reflect betting activity as well as performance. Anyone wagering should stay within their budget and check the legal rules where they live.

What could still change the race

Three weeks is a long time in a Heisman race. Here's what to watch:

  • Rivalry week. Big rivalry games often produce the clips that define a season.
  • Conference championship games. They give contenders one more high-stakes, nationally televised audition.
  • Team results. A candidate on a team that stumbles can lose ground quickly, even with strong stats.
  • Injuries and availability. A missed game or a limited workload can freeze a candidate's totals.
  • Voting timeline. Heisman voting usually closes shortly after the regular season ends, with finalists announced and the ceremony held in December. Check official Heisman announcements for exact dates.

What it means for fans

If you follow the race casually, the simple takeaway is that Smith's candidacy is getting more serious and the field is not settled. The 4,000-yard milestone gives his supporters a concrete talking point, but voters will most likely focus on what he and Ohio State do in the biggest remaining games.

If you track odds closely, compare a few sources and look at the trend rather than a single snapshot. A one-week move can reflect one big game. A steady climb over several weeks says more.

What to watch next

Watch the next round of odds after this weekend's games, the NCAA.com contender rankings as they update, and any further Ohio State milestones. This story is still developing, and the market could look quite different by the time finalists are named.

Shop the trend

Ohio State Buckeyes fan jersey

A natural pick for readers following Jeremiah Smith and the Buckeyes' season.

Check price on Amazon →
Heisman Trophy history book

Gives background on past winners and how the award has changed.

Check price on Amazon →
College football watch party serving set

Useful for hosting friends for the final weeks of the season.

Check price on Amazon →

Prices and availability change; see Amazon for current details. Paid links.

Coverage & sources

#heisman odds#heisman trophy#jeremiah smith#ohio state#college football#mestemaker